Senator Feingold Wants a Withdrawal Timetable for Afghanistan

Posted: August 25, 2009 in Uncategorized
Tags: , ,

In an editorial board meeting with the Appleton Post-Crescent, Senator Russ Feingold (D-WI) said it’s time for a withdrawal timetable for our forces in Afghanistan. Feingold was the first U.S. Senator to publicly state the need for a withdrawal date from Iraq. Today he became the first senator to say the same about our war in Afghanistan.

“After eight years, I am not convinced that simply pouring more and more troops into Afghanistan is a well thought out strategy.  And I have raised this issue with the President, with the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Admiral Mullen, Mr. Holbrooke, the special representative to the area, and everybody else I can and have never been convinced that they have a good answer to the concern that I have, and that other people have.

It’s not surprising Feingold is dissatisfied with answers from Holbrooke and Gates. The former gave an uninspiring definition of success in Afghanistan: “We’ll know it when we see it.” The latter called how long we’d be fighting an active war in Afghanistan a “mystery.”

Feingold continued:

“So something I have not said before which I want to say here in Appleton is that I think it is time we ought to start discussing a flexible timetable when people in America and Afghanistan and around the world can see where we intend and when we intend to bring our troops out…

(Four) years ago I was the first senator in the United States – I announced it in Marquette, Wisconsin – to say we ought to have a timetable for Iraq.  I believe that activism was important in moving us forward and having elections where people said it’s time to finish it.

“So we have to be dead serious about security.  We have to maintain the ability to go after al Qaeda within Afghanistan.  It doesn’t mean we give that up.  But simply continuing operations there – and apparently there are going to be requests for many more troops – I’m not sure it’s a wise idea.”

Feingold has been out in front on this issue all year. Speaking with Jeremy Scahill on June 24, 2009, Feingold said:

“This is something I’ve been trying to hammer away at,” Feingold tells The Nation. “They admitted that it’s a problem, but where’s the follow-up? This administration is almost whistling past the graveyard on this issue.

Bravo, Senator Feingold.

(Derrick Crowe is the Afghanistan blog fellow for Brave New Foundation / The Seminal. You can learn more about the threat the Afghanistan war poses to our security at Rethink Afghanistan, or by watching the latest segment, “Security,” on YouTube.)

  1. sporkmaster says:

    A post to read before I can put a real comment on this.

  2. sporkmaster says:

    Ok one concern is the the time line. This is not a business project for a new product line where they want a date when it will be finished and ready for use. How can you expect to know how this ends when the renewed effort to help Afghanistan even gets started in full. (Which would mean extra troops, something that was need there since 2002.)

    There are so many variables in this that to even plan what will happen in war is very hard. There was the expectation that WW2 would be over before Christmas of 1944. Look how well that worked.

    Also what happens when the Military officers say that the time needed is inconvenient for Senator Feingold and others? Will he try to push for a total withdrawal and if so how will that help

    Yes violence is going up to Afghanistan, but I have to wonder how that is with the general reduction of violence in Iraq? To me it seems that they are going to Afghanistan along being pushed out of Pakistan by the it’s army there.

    Also with the election, compare the results in Iraq in 2005 against 2009 after the surge. That is one of the reason why the increase could help.

  3. […] Senator Feingold Wants a Withdrawal Timetable for Afghanistan posted on August 31st, 2009 at Return Good for Evil […]

  4. […] George Will and Senator Russ Feingold agree on something, you better listen to […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s